How to choose an SEO agency: a 12-question checklist for vendors
Choosing an SEO vendor almost always happens under information asymmetry: the agency knows more about SEO than the client. This guide levels the field — it includes selection criteria, interview questions for the vendor, and warning signs that should make you walk away.
Step 1. Define the goal in business metrics
The most common reason a partnership fails is a different understanding of the outcome. "We want to be in the top" is not a goal: rankings don't pay salaries. A real goal sounds like "increase organic-search leads from 40 to 100 per month within 9 months" or "reduce the cost per organic lead below the cost of paid traffic."
A clear goal immediately filters out vendors who only work with traffic and aren't willing to be accountable for conversions.
Step 2. Check relevant experience, not just years on the market
Experience in your niche matters more than the total number of years in business. An agency that has promoted 20 online stores will likely deliver results for e-commerce faster than a generalist with a decade of experience in B2B services.
- •Ask for 2–3 case studies specifically from your niche or a comparable business model.
- •Check whether the case study shows before-and-after numbers, not just a growth screenshot.
- •Ask exactly which work was done by the agency and which by the client.
Step 3. 12 questions worth asking
- •Who exactly will run the project, and how many hours per month are allocated?
- •What does the first month of the engagement look like?
- •Which work is included in the monthly budget, and what is billed separately?
- •Who writes the content, and is that included in the price?
- •How do you work with developers on our side?
- •What metrics will appear in the monthly report?
- •How soon should we expect the first changes, and by which indicators?
- •Do you have experience with our CMS?
- •How do you build the link profile, and which sources do you use?
- •What happens to the work done if we end the partnership?
- •Are you open to a pilot month or an audit before signing a contract?
- •Who makes the final call if our opinion and your recommendation differ?
Step 4. Warning signs
- •A guarantee of specific rankings by a set deadline.
- •Refusing to show any case studies "due to NDA," without exception.
- •A report that only lists rankings and completed tasks, with no business metrics.
- •A price significantly below market rate, with no explanation of why.
- •Reluctance to discuss access handover and transfer of completed work.
Step 5. Compare proposals correctly
Compare not the total price of a proposal, but the amount of work behind that price: hours, team composition, content volume, number of links. A cheaper proposal with half the hours is not a bargain.
The optimal starting point is an audit or a pilot month. It's a cheaper way to test the team's communication and quality of thinking than a year-long contract.
Frequently asked questions
Read also
Looking for a vendor?
Compare agencies by transparent rating, city and industry.